American Elephants

The Information From a Government Shutdown May Be More Important than We Realize! by The Elephant's Child


During President Trump’s government shutdown, the partisan media daily gave us a play-by-play account of the agonies of government workers, clearly starving to death and unable to pay for food or fun. Several major banks offered no-interest loans, many DC restaurants offered free meals, and if any federal employees wanted to complain about their horrific treatment, the breathless media was right there with a microphone and a camera.

It should be a lesson to all federal workers, put aside six months of savings. Presidents do try shutdowns now and then, and it’s nice to be prepared. A few dollars at a time works. However the reality on the ground didn’t seem to indicate that furloughed employees suffered enough to satisfy the media.

Perhaps you recall President Obama’s government shutdown. He shut down all the national parks, tried to block viewpoints where people could look into national parks, and shut down federal monuments in Washington D.C. which meant that the special flights bringing elderly WWII veterans to see their monument in the nation’s capitol spoiled their visit. And younger, more able vets took it on themselves to take down the barriers. This time around the drama was all in the press, and there was no attempt to inconvenience ordinary citizens.

Of course Democrats are now trying to come up with a bill that prevents shutting down the government when Republicans are in charge while not interfering with their own ventures.

It’s all theater, of course. What a government shutdown actually does demonstrate is that there are a remarkable number of tasks performed by federal workers that would be better done by the private sector, and quite a lot that don’t need to be done at all. A correspondent for Reason said there was a story in his local paper that National Park Rangers were fining “trespassers” at sites including the Montezuma Well Indian ruins. But that wasn’t quite accurate., the site is free to enter and the small ranger station there is often unstaffed.

Air Traffic Control is, however, a job that needs to be done. A recent report from the U.S. Department of Transportation’s Inspector General pointed out that Canada, the U.K. Germany and France have “commercialized their air t traffic operations via independent air navigation service providers” that “are financially self-supporting.” He added that we could learn from their experience. The Airline trade association supports privatization, and industry analysts say the shutdown gave them a bi boost.

We already know that government workers are paid significantly more than their counterparts in the private sector, for no particular reason except that it’s easy for Congress to approve constantly growing budgets. It’s not something that gets attention from their voters at election time.

Do make the effort to write to your representatives and tell them what you think. They may not read your actual letter or email, but if you are a constituent your opinion gets tallied and the fact that you troubled to write gives it extra importance. You might turn out to be an activist.

3 Comments so far
Leave a comment

During President Trump’s government shutdown, the partisan media daily gave us a play-by-play account of the agonies of government workers, clearly starving to death and unable to pay for food or fun

As accurate as everything else they offer– nobody paid a bit of attention to my husband, or anybody else on Instanpundit (and there are several folks) who said “Yep, we are furloughed, we’re fine, charge on Trump!” but they gave HOURS of attention to folks with “halp we no haz cash” before any paycheck had been missed.


For anybody wanting to attack our generosity– we have, and have since way before the shutdown, a policy of inviting folks we know who might maybe possibly be interested in having leftovers for the rest of the week over for dinner and “game night,” we have good food and lots of it, and try to insist folks take food home. Even if the DON’T need it, the folks where both adults have paying jobs can use a night or three of someone else’s cooking, even if it’s mine.

Liked by 1 person

Comment by Foxfier

Air Traffic Control may be necessary but Europe has switched over to a computerized air traffic control system years ago. It works quite well. It’s cheaper to operate and much more reliable. Here in the U.S., the hordes of air traffic controllers are no longer necessary except to pay their unions which contribute to the reelection of pliable politicians. North American ATC needs to join the 21st century.


Comment by Jay Dee

There doesn’t seem to be any viable reason why it is a U.S. government job. We should take advantage of the information that is exposed by a shutdown. Might as well get some good out of it.


Comment by The Elephant's Child

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: